Coinbase Faces Supreme Court Defeat in Dogecoin Sweepstakes Lawsuit
Release: 2024/05/24 18:44 Reading: 649
- Original author：BeInCrypto
- Original source：https://beincrypto.com/?p=520060
In a Decisive Unanimous Ruling, the US Supreme Court Sides Against Coinbase
In a decisive unanimous ruling, the US Supreme Court has ruled against Coinbase in a class-action lawsuit stemming from its 2021 Dogecoin sweepstakes. The high-profile case, resolved on May 23, revolved around a promotional event promising prizes totaling up to $1.2 million.
How Coinbase Lost the Legal Battle
The lawsuit was initiated by participant David Suski and others, who alleged that Coinbase, along with the sweepstakes management company, violated California's False Advertising Law, Unfair Competition Law, and Consumer Legal Remedies Act by misleading participants.
The crux of the dispute was Coinbase's effort to enforce arbitration based on its user agreement, which a District Court decided also applied to the sweepstakes agreement. The Supreme Court's ruling supported the District Court's decision, clarifying that disputes related to the sweepstakes are to be adjudicated in state and federal courts. This effectively nullifies the arbitration clause that would typically mandate dispute resolution through a third party without court involvement.
Implications of the Ruling
This outcome marked a significant legal defeat for Coinbase, which preferred arbitration as the dispute resolution method. Following the decision, Paul Grewal, Coinbase's Chief Legal Officer, expressed mixed feelings.
"What a week. Some you win. Some you lose. We are grateful for having had the opportunity to present our case to the Court and appreciate the Court's consideration of this matter," Grewal said.
Legal commentators have keenly analyzed the implications of this ruling. Stephen Carter, a Bloomberg Opinion columnist, pointed out a fundamental oversight by Coinbase's legal team. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, writing for the court, noted an essential inconsistency: the existence of two contracts.
The User Agreement included an arbitration clause. However, the Official Rules of the sweepstakes, which all entrants had to agree to, mentioned nothing about arbitration. Instead, they included a forum selection clause assigning exclusive jurisdiction to California courts over any disputes. This inconsistency was pivotal to the Supreme Court's decision, revealing a significant legal error.
"The contracts professor in me ventures to suggest, as gently and respectfully as possible, that the company's lawyers should have foreseen this problem and ensured that the two contracts reflected a single, clear proposition," Carter explained.
The ruling might significantly influence future legal frameworks within the crypto industry, highlighting the necessity for clear, consistent legal terms in user agreements and promotional rules.
Recent news
More>- PEPE Now Available for New York Users to Trade on Coinbase 11-28
- Tether Discontinues Support for EURT Stablecoin: Here’s Why 11-28
- Best Trending Meme Coins in December 2024: 6.5 Billion Coins Sold in BTFD Coin’s Ongoing Presale, Pepe Coin and Ponke on the Rise 11-28
- As Top Cryptos Recover After Recent Dip, New Meme Coin Pepe Unchained’s Unstoppable Presale Powers Ahead — Only 16 Days Left 11-28
- As Top Cryptos Recover After Recent Dip, New Meme Coin Pepe Unchained’s Unstoppable Presale Powers Ahead — Only 16 Days Left 11-28
- As Top Cryptos Recover After Recent Dip, New Meme Coin Pepe Unchained’s Unstoppable Presale Powers Ahead — Only 16 Days Left 11-28
- Missed PEPE? Don’t Miss Out on This New Token That’s Breaking Records at Lightning Speed 11-28
- CHILLGUY meme coin could be at risk as smart money sells 11-28
- Top Trending Meme Coins to Buy in 2025: BTFD Coin Presale Raises Over $150,000 in Less Than 24 Hours Since Going Live, Dogecoin and Dogs Gro... 11-28
Selected Topics
More>>-
- pepecoin Price Analysis
- This topic provides articles related to PepeCoin price, covering key PepeCoin insights and analysis
-
- pepe:meme star
- This topic provides articles related to the most promising meme, PEPECOIN, a project with the potential to become a mainstream digital currency. It has the advantages of decentralization, reliability, ease of use, fast speed, low cost and scalability, and is expected to be more widely used in the future
-
- pepecoin price prediction
- We’ve gathered facts about pepecoin’s success story and provided a pepecoin price prediction
Selected Articles
More>>- 1 Avalanche and Aptos rival raises over $600k in 2 weeks
- 2 Crypto Prices Today: Market Continues Rally With BTC, Pepe Coin, SEI Rising
- 3 Major Analyst Crypto Tony Bullish on These Meme Coins, But One Stands Out
- 4 MTAUR Ready to Crush DOGE and PEPE: 100x Price Growth Incoming?
- 5 Memecoins Surge in 2024, Popcat Leads with 7,621% YTD Gain, Outshining Top Crypto Tokens
- 6 PEPE Meme Coin Smashes ATH – See How Much an $83 Investment in Pepe Coin Last Year is Worth Now
- 7 Top 4 Altcoins At 70% Discounts – Last Chance!
- 8 Dogecoin Creator Proposes DOGE to NBA Legend Scottie Pippen
- 9 Top Analyst Who Predicted Dogecoin (DOGE) Last 170x Rally Forecasts New Parabolic Rise, Here’s His Price Target
- 10 New Solana Memecoin Trump Loves Elon to Rally 15,000% Before Exchange Listing, SHIB and Bonk Crash
ABOUT US
We are building the most influential，trusted information platform for aglobal community engaged in thd transformation of the financial system andthe emerging crypto economy.PEPE is an integrated platform for media,events,data & indices for the next generation fo investing and the future of money.
Get in touch with the PEPE team at admin@pepecoinbuy.com